Visit the ACCC COVID-19 Resource Center & Discussion Group for Insights on Providing Optimal Patient Care During the Pandemic.
 

Share

    


In This Section

Home / Learn / Oncology Team Well-Being

Oncology Team Well-Being

Mini-Z Survey Results

Results from Mini Z Burnout Survey

To gauge the level of burnout in the multidisciplinary cancer care team, ACCC recently surveyed its membership using the clinically validated Mini Z survey developed by the American Medical Association. While only a small number of respondents (14.9%) report dissatisfaction with their current job, burnout and stress levels are significant.
Download Survey Infographic

Cancer Buzz Podcast

Other ACCC Resources

ACCC Institute for the Future of Oncology


The sixth annual ACCC Institute held in Washington, D.C., on June 27, 2018, convened more than 30 experts in cancer care, wellness, and resiliency to share insights on what is fueling burnout among members of the cancer care team and what needs to happen on both on both a micro and macro level to support and improve team well-being. The day-long forum discussion focused on ACCC President Tom Gallo’s 2018-2019 presidential theme: Reflect, Renew, Reignite: Creating a Resilient Oncology Team in Your Community.
Read the Executive Summary

ND19-cover-306x411

Breaking Down Silos: Revenue Cycle Tiers Increase Efficiency and Reduce Waste
By Pamela R. Proman, MBA, RTT; William D. James, MHA; and Nancy H. Johnson, MSM


After a review of key performance indicators, including charge lag, month-end close, patient registration, and insurance identification and verification, this cancer program leveraged its EHR and billing data to identify actionable areas for improvement. Four primary impacts of silo mentality were identified: resource waste, incorrect denials, reduced cash flow, and increased risk for financial toxicity. Performance improvements were prioritized using a matrix to grade urgency and importance.
Read Article

 

Whose Burnout Is It?


September 23, 2019
icon-leave-a-comment
Tetzlaff-Eric_headshot

The risks, nature, and repercussions of burnout among members of the cancer care team have been discussed at length. But burnout does not always manifest itself in the same way from clinician to clinician and among supportive care professionals.

Eric D. Tetzlaff, MHS, PA-C, DFAAPA, a physician assistant at Fox Chase Cancer Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, studies how workplace stress affects physician assistants (PAs) in particular. Tetzlaff recently received a grant from the Association of Physician Assistants in Oncology (APAO) to study burnout among oncology PAs during a three-year period. This longitudinal study will track PA burnout by focusing on several factors that can stem from the individual, the team they work with, and the unique characteristics of their organizations. Results will be based on participant responses and evaluated to determine the extent of burnout. Tetzlaff will explore whether PAs are at an increased risk of burnout, if that risk changes over time, and if burnout has caused some PAs to seek work in another subspecialty or to leave the field of medicine entirely.

ACCCBuzz: Are PAs more susceptible to burnout than other members of the oncology care team?

Tetzlaff: Physician assistants are not necessarily more at risk for being burned out than nurse practitioners or our physician colleagues in oncology. The rates of burnout are high for all three. There does appear to be some differences in the rate of burnout among the subspecialties within oncology, with the highest rates in PAs specializing in medical oncology, and lower rates in PAs specializing in surgical and radiation oncology.   

ACCCBuzz: Do PAs exhibit any specific burnout symptoms that nurses and oncologists might not?

Tetzlaff: The symptoms of burnout are likely similar. However, we noted in our 2017 study of burnout and career satisfaction among PAs that there did seem to be a slightly lower sense of personal accomplishment for oncology PAs when compared to reported rates for medical oncologists. I think some of that may be due to the way that PAs are practicing medicine and supporting the oncology team. Oncology PAs may be spending more time on indirect patient care and less time on the more personally meaningful, direct patient-care tasks. It is possible that some of the tasks PAs are asked to complete are not satisfying and are considered below their level of training. When people enter medicine, they are looking to go into it for very altruistic reasons—to help others.

Completing Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) forms, return-to-work forms, prior authorization requests, or similar tasks actually take away from the time that you spend face-to-face with a patient, and it can diminish the sense of meaning and personal accomplishment that many providers desire. It’s very likely that some of those tasks are being delegated to PAs in oncology and are not being done by our physician colleagues as much. That could certainly be a part of it, as you’re looking to balance the work between the two.

ACCCBuzz: Do you have advice for other cancer programs that want to counteract burnout in PAs?

Tetzlaff: I think the most important thing to do is to first ask which groups in an organization have the highest rates of burnout—not necessarily in relation to their peers at their institution, but in relation to the reported rates for a given specialty or discipline. Make sure you have resources available to physician assistants and help them find that balance between paperwork and patient care and work/life balance. It’s also important to understand the team dynamics and clinical support available, and whether these factors change or stay the same. Do PAs have control or influence over their team or the larger institution in which they work so they feel really connected as a member of their team or institution?

ACCCBuzz: What have you noticed through your career that might not work when addressing PA burnout?

Tetzlaff: I think for a long time there was an effort to try to help the individual develop the skill set needed to combat or deal with burnout. I think in some ways it placed the blame on the individual as opposed to looking at the institution’s responsibility as well.

It’s not a single individual’s lack of resilience that leads to burnout. There are lots of different factors—some of which are institutionally based—whether it is lack of control over your work environment, lack of control over the people with whom who you work, or the development of moral distress among team members. These are more infrastructure, team-based, or organizational factors. Programs that focus on the individual alone are not nearly as successful as efforts that focus on both the individual and the organization. 

Take a deeper dive into this topic. Find ACCC resources and strategies to promote resilience and well-being among cancer care team members here. Listen to this episode of CANCER BUZZ for a conversation focused on why institutional buy-in is a "must have" to address burnout in the healthcare workplace.  Then, read the latest case studies from the NAM's Action Collaborative on Clinician Well-being and Resilience.

The opinions expressed in this blog post are not necessarily those of ACCC or our member organizations. We encourage you to share our blog posts. You may reproduce our posts either in part or in full, or you may link to specific posts. Images may not be used or distributed. Any reproduction must link back to the original source. Do not alter the text of our materials, and cite the source as follows: “[blog title] was first published on [date] by the Association of Community Cancer Centers.” For more information, visit our Terms of Use.

 

From Oncology Issues

  • Improving Cancer Care by Addressing Food Insecurity
    Tracey F. Weisberg, MD
    Our results indicated that food insecure patients tended to complete fewer months of treatment than their food secure counterparts. Food insecure patients who refused assistance had the lowest number of months of completed treatment; most food insecure patients who received assistance completed more of their treatment.
  • Go Viral with Compassion and Kindness
    Jennie R. Crews, MD, MMM, FACP, AND Krista Nelson, MSW, LCSW, OSW-C, BCD
    What can those experiencing cancer and its overwhelming unpredictability teach us about dealing with COVID-19?
  •  How to Combat a Virus
    Jennie Crews, MD, MMM, FACP
  •  Can You Hear Me Now?
    Kimberly Smith, MPHA
    After integrating voice recognition software with its EMR, Mount Sinai Health System reduced physician workload, improved patient care, and streamlined clinic workflow. Physicians and staff shared that this process improvement initiative also improved their well-being, freeing clinicians up to spend more time doing what they want to do—caring for patients.
  •  Caring for the Caregiver
    April Alexander, MSW, LCSW, OSW-C, et al.
    A holistic Self-Care and Resiliency Program for Oncology Professionals has helped to decrease oncology staff burnout rates. Key components include Patient Remembrance Ceremonies, staff support groups, educational opportunities, and social events.
  •  Breaking Down Silos
    Pamela R. Proman, MBA, RTT, et al.
    Using its EHR and billing data to examine key metrics—including charge lag, patient registration, and insurance verification—the Nancy N. and J. C. Lewis Cancer & Research Pavilion at St. Joseph’s/Candler identified four key effects of the “silo mentality” on its cancer program. Focusing on efficiency and urgency, the program broke down its silos, reducing waste and incorrect denials, improving cash flow, and alleviating patient—and program—financial toxicity.
  •  Utilizing Scribes to Improve Patient-Centered Care and Efficiency and Reduce Burnout
    By Amy Hindman
    More oncology programs across the country are hiring scribes in their practices to improve patient-centered care, reduce physician burnout, and create administrative efficiencies.
  •  Caring for the Caregiver
    By ACCC Editorial Staff
    Dr. Farley directs Christiana Care Health System’s strategy to promote the professional fulfillment and personal well-being of its caregivers—and, subsequently, its patients.
  •  Burnout Prevention & Education
    By Monique Dawkins, EDD, MPA, et al.
    Being aware of how burnout manifests itself can help supervisors and staff identify the condition early.
  • Small in Stature, Large in Impact
    By ACCC Editorial Staff
    Caring for patients with cancer is inherently stressful, but many cancer team members say that their difficulties go beyond the expected emotional strain. Robin Hearne, RN, MS, director of Cancer Services and Chronic Disease Care at The Outer Banks Hospital, elaborates on the burdens of bureaucracy and shares the programs she’s developed to provide staff with necessary tools for patient and self-care.

Burnout is on the rise as oncology becomes increasingly complex with new treatment options, growing financial toxicity, an aging patient population, and an increasingly burdensome healthcare system. It has received much media attention, with some calling it an epidemic.

Thomas A. Gallo, MS, MDA, ACCC President, selected his 2018–2019 president’s theme: Reflect, Renew, Reignite: Creating a Resilient Oncology Team in Your Community, in order to shed light on the pain points that frustrate physicians, nurses, social workers, administrators, pharmacists, and all of the other professionals who collaborate to provide the highest level of patient care.

The ACCC 35th National Oncology Conference, October 17 – 19, in Phoenix, AZ, featured stories and strategies for fostering resilience and a healthcare culture that mitigates burnout among all members of the cancer care team. Three featured speakers inspired while providing practical strategies to help increase engagement, transform your work culture, and embrace experimentation. 

6 essential standards for a healthy work environment

ACCC is committed to identifying shared strategies and solutions to help combat the burnout and frustration that many of its members experience. This Building a Resilient Oncology Team: Issues and Solutions infographic details key findings on clinician burnout and a bevy of solutions to help you mitigate stress and bring the joy back to your workplace. 
Download as PDF
Or click each thumbnail below to view full size version:

Resilient Oncology Team Page 1Page 1
Resilient Oncology Team Page 2Page 2